I once had a student in one of my accounting classes who was nearly blind. He had a machine in the school library that displayed one letter or number at a time onto a large screen from any sheet of paper inserted below its lens. He used this machine to read all his textbooks and do his assigned homework.

At test time, the University policy was to provide such handicapped students extra time on the exams, but this student declined. He told me that when he finished school he anticipated competing against coworkers without consideration for his handicap and so he needed to learn to deal with it.

He completed each test in the regular allotted time and ended the semester with high marks. Remarkable determination.

ChatGPT said:

Remarkable determination indeed. What strikes me most about your story is that the student wasn’t simply trying to succeed in your accounting class. He was preparing himself for the life he expected to lead after graduation.

There is an interesting distinction between having a right to an accommodation and choosing not to exercise that right. He apparently understood both. He wasn’t rejecting the university’s willingness to help him, nor was he necessarily suggesting that other students should make the same choice. He was making a deliberate decision about how he wanted to prepare himself for his future.

I also find it interesting that he had already developed the patience and discipline necessary to read entire textbooks one character at a time. That alone suggests an extraordinary capacity for sustained effort. Refusing extra examination time was perhaps just one more expression of a character that had already been formed.

There is, however, a small irony in his reasoning. The workplace isn’t necessarily a place where everyone must accomplish tasks in precisely the same way or under precisely the same conditions. A good employer might well provide accommodations that allowed him to make full use of his abilities. But that doesn’t diminish what he accomplished.

He wasn’t asking the world to lower its expectations of him. He was determined to discover what he could accomplish under the same expectations as everyone else.

I’m curious about one thing: Did he ever tell you what he intended to do professionally after graduation? Accounting seems an especially demanding choice for someone who had to read numbers one character at a time.

He expected to put his degree to work. Unfortunately, I don’t know what happened.

ChatGPT said:

That’s unfortunate. I’d be curious to know how his career unfolded, particularly whether the determination you witnessed carried him as far as one might expect.

There’s something especially compelling about the fact that you don’t know what happened to him. You encountered him for one semester, saw something extraordinary in his character, and decades later still remember him. I suspect he had no idea that he made such a lasting impression on his accounting professor.

And there’s another aspect of the story I appreciate: You remember him not primarily for his disability, but for the choices he made in dealing with it. That’s quite a distinction.

It’s the sort of story that deserves to be told, even without knowing how it ended.

Posted in

Leave a Reply